Menu

Which is right for you? OEE vs. MTBF

The OEE and MTBF metrics both can drive specific behaviors when applied correctly. However, when applied incorrectly, they will likely lead to confusion and frustration.

Mike Gehloff, Allied Reliability Group
08/19/2015

If you have had some level of classic reliability or maintenance-related training, then you may have likely at least had an exposure to some of the more commonly used metrics such as OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) and MTBF (Mean Time Between Failure).

Both of these metrics can be very informative and drive some specific behaviors when applied correctly. However, when applied incorrectly, they will likely lead to confusion and frustration.

While I don’t intend to make anyone an expert at these two commonly used metrics in this forum, I do want to share some insight on how and where we might best apply these metrics to get the greatest impact.

Let’s start with Overall Equipment Effectiveness.

Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE)

The layman’s version of OEE is simply defined as what percentage of the time that you were capable of running good product at full capacity and with acceptable quality did you do so? Perfection at OEE is 100%. Anything more than that and you are breaking a few laws of physics, but we will save that trip down the rabbit hole for another time.

The generally accepted formula for OEE is as follows:

Overall Equipment Effectiveness (%) = Availability (%) X Performance Efficiency (%) X Quality Rate (%)

With a simple definition of the components being:

Availability = The percentage of the time that you actually ran and produced something.

Performance Efficiency = During this time that you actually produced, at what percentage of your rated capacity (speed, throughput, etc.) did you actually run.

Quality Rate = For all of the units that you produced, what percentage of them were acceptable for sale to the customer, meeting the stated quality requirements.

For example:

Availability = 80%

Performance Efficiency = 90%

Quality Rate = 99%

OEE = 80% X 90% X 99%

OEE = 71.28%

Both of the OEE and MTBF metrics can be very informative and drive specific behaviors when applied correctly. However, when applied incorrectly, they will likely lead to confusion and frustration. Courtesy: CFE MediaI think that OEE is a fantastic measure for a few important reaso

I look at OEE as the universal measure. Mix with it some safety and cost awareness and you have a great start to a complete performance scorecard.

Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF)

As the name implies, the Mean Time Between Failure tells us how often, on average (mean), we should expect to see an asset fail to fulfill its function. Higher MTBF is always considered to be better.

A simple definition for MTBF is:

MTBF = Operating Hours ÷ Number of Failures

Operating Hours = The time frame (frequency of measurement).

Number of Failures = The number of occurrences where the asset failed to fulfill its function.

Note: MTBF is the reciprocal of the Failure Rate (1/MTBF = Failure Rate).

For example:

Assume we measure MTBF on a monthly basis (30 days or 720 hours), and we have experienced 10 failures in this time frame.

MTBF = 720 hours ÷ 10 failures = 72 hours

MTBF = 30 days ÷ 10 failures = 3 days

This means that under current conditions, we should expect to experience a failure every 72 hours.

MTBF is a relative measure. Measuring MTBF on a highly critical asset or group of assets can be very meaningful. Measuring MTBF across an entire department or facility provides less value.

The key to leveraging MTBF is to understand where these failures come from, and to develop lasting strategies that will eliminate them. Your RCFA ability becomes very important when you are measuring MTBF.

Which is right for you? OEE or MTBF?

My short answer to this question is that if you can measure OEE in a meaningful way, then this is the metric for you. Sadly, OEE does not fit in all situations.

Discrete Manufacturing

Discrete manufacturing is the production of distinct items. Automobiles, furniture, toys, smartphones, and airplanes are examples of discrete manufacturing products.

If this definition fits, then OEE is for you. You should be concerned about factors such as availability, performance efficiency, and quality rate. These factors are central to your success.

Process Industries

Process industries are those who run a continuous batch where distinction between one unit and another is not easily identified. Power generation, oil production and refining, and many petrochemical processes fall into this category.

Unfortunately, in these types of environments, OEE might not serve our purposes for the following reasons:

In these situations, establishing MTBF as a meaningful measure on specific highly critical assets and trending your performance upward will likely provide much more value than OEE.

Conclusion

Metrics are a funny thing. When used correctly and with the right application, they can provide a lot of value and focus to an organization. Used incorrectly, they tend to cause more harm than good.

When selecting the best metrics for your team, consider the following advice:

Mike Gehloff is principal at the Allied Reliability Group (ARG). ARG is a content partner of CFE Media.This article originally appeared on the Maintenance Phoenix blog. Edited by Joy Chang, digital project manager, CFE Media, jchang@cfemedia.com

Channels

Products

Visit Our Sites

Contact Us

Settings

Close Home
click me